I didn’t forget
December 11, 2008
Strange that insistence on being taken seriously in your personal experience of the political is so unsettling.
You speak your pain, and people rush to soothe it, settle it, quiet it; but if you speak again, to say ‘That’s not quite right’, consternation seems to arise. Frustration: be a good girl and play quietly please the adults want to have a nice settled time.
Do you think I’m claiming victim status? Because I put the blame where it belongs? Because I try to show you that I didn’t invent this in my silly little head? That I insist on pointing back to the source of the pain (and I know I am not the only one who feels it, that is the point entirely) – shining my feeble penlight in the dark at the webs? Trying to remark on points of connectedness? Trying to articulate what I see, trying to keep moving without drowning, without being bound by what I feel sticking to me? Discussing the patterns I’ve noticed? Pointing them out since they’re there and others *must* have noticed…
Why do you think that admitting pain is the same as claiming a bereft sort of weakness. Whatever I am it isn’t weak. I am tall and strong, rangy and loud. I stand with my feet firmly planted and my tongue ready – this body is tired because it has been through more than enough for each of its years. But why should acknowledging that be read as being ‘weak’, claiming the ‘benifit’ of victimhood. Fuck. I survive, I flourish, I throw my head back and laugh. To feel pain is not weakness, to really feel it, to honestly grieve gives strength.
But you know, don’t you that it’s bigger than any of us? That I can be as strong as I want, “Strong like an Amazon” but nothing changes, the webs are still there? So why make it about *victim mentality*. Isn’t it easier to just look where I point, to acknowledge that you’ve seen it too? I’m not asking you to solve it. But stop pretending that I’m crazy, or ‘just angry’ or wallowing, or wanting ’special treatment’.
Does writing on what makes me angry reduce me in your eyes to only anger? Do people not see that I have joy? Can they not see that through my writing? In the barbs, and the twists of words? In the tongue in cheek puns? In the sheer ferocity of my writing? It isn’t clean, pure, polished writing, it is writing that pours forth, I try not to hold it back, it shouts, it roars, it pours forth like a stream, it contradicts itself, it splits and fractures and it LAUGHS. It isn’t writing that will change the world…but I have found my voice and I will always speak, shout, laugh and sing.
What I say will change, will flow, will split and morph, will fold back upon itself and gush forward again. I refuse the linear narrative path set out for me, I reject it (even as it has already constituted me), I say no to jumping for class approval, I spit in the face of The Canon and I laugh when I sin against The Holy Church of Grammar. I embrace the insult hurled at women…we prattle, we waffle, we drift. Yeah? Take a face full of prattle then and see how it feels. No I am not One of The Greats, but I am great. Me, all of me.
Arrogance? No, joy. I have love and rage and deep bellowing lungs, long limbs, and teeth that flash like knives though we both know I don’t bite to draw blood (very often). And at night I remember that strength lets me lie like a baby and croon to my lover.I enjoy the strength in being bare and vulnerable, happy and warm. I love to love.
I didn’t forget any of this when I spoke of what the world does to women. I know who I am, who I am becoming, I know I am bigger than this, that this will pass…but I am smaller than it also, a cog, a unit, a flea in a system that does not care, and that thrives on silence, acquiesance and politeness.
Hence the blog name, hence the posts. Do I think I’m a revolutionary? No. But I think if we all talked more – really really talked, talked without fear of being laughed at, spoke the things we thought were crazy, told of the things we hid away, it could be an explosion of sorts.
fuck politeness indeed
I think you are Great if not The Great, what an awesome post to read in the morning.
Thank you
Thanks AD…
I have been meaning to reply to your comments, but life got a little rushed and the momentum of the reactions to blog posts (or their topics) meant that I was running to keep up.
But thanks. It’s a bizarre feeling putting a piece of writing like that out there. Wondering if it’s crap/self indulgent/whatever, so it’s nice to have positive feedback.
Oy FP, apublicblogging here, I said it at Hoyden and I’ll say it here, I really hope nothing I said in response to that post sounded like I construed weakness or victimhood.
“But I think if we all talked more – really really talked, talked without fear of being laughed at, spoke the things we thought were crazy, told of the things we hid away, it could be an explosion of sorts.”
Oh yeah. It was women getting together for consciousness-raising sessions, and finally talking, that sparked so many reforms in the 1970s.
An older wiser and greater (than me) feminist whom I work with occasionally, has said for a while now that “it’s time for consciousness-raising again” and I agree.
I thought there was genuine empathy on the thread at Hoyden, though not necessarily all in the spirit of consciousness-raising.
Hey Linda…
No, look, nothing you said sounded like that at all, and it’s not even directed necessarily at responses there…it’s just a kind of rambly post about something I’ve noticed in general, that when women speak up and insist on articulating themselves fully it often rubs people up the wrong way…
Fine chose words poorly, and there’s no long lasting problem there. Laura and I have ended up in a stoush which started for me when she told Theriomorph she was ‘just wrong’ to assert that my post was not just personal but also political. I get grumpy with ‘just wrong’, and I get grumpier when I try to point something out and am evaded, misconstrued, and dismissed with snide comments. Whatever.
This post was just me attempting to write in a different way I guess…and the victimhood bit is something I feel coming up as a resistance to feminism a lot.
So no problems there at all…just me attempting to articulate an overall feeling that girls and women are asked to not talk about their feelings etc.
Oh and really, 99 percent of that thread I had no issue with I thought it started some great discussions.
“that when women speak up and insist on articulating themselves fully it often rubs people up the wrong way”
I think know what you mean. When I mention feminism/patriarchy/oppression whatever to other non-feminist women, they often interpret it as victimhood and I get responses like “Oh you just have to find it in yourself to overcome all that crap! You can do it!”
It’s totally alienating and I never know how to respond to it.
Yeah, that’s the sort of stuff I’m trying to get at, and it feels connected to the messages to girls “Sit still, stay clean, knees together, don’t run, don’t talk back, play nice, be quiet”. Not to mention the worship of the ‘nice girl’. FFS. My entire childhood I heard my parents talk about how this or that girl was ’so NICE’. And what it meant was that she smiled a lot, had developed the ‘appropriate’ social skills, and was never frowning, getting dirty, having her head too buried in a book or blurting things out bluntly. She was shiny. Gaargh. Give me fun/kind/empathetic/opinionated and interesting over “NICE” any day of the week. I honestly don’t know how to handle people who are over the top ‘nice’. It’s like they may as well be conversing with the wall or something, their maniacal grin and enthusiasm would be there no matter who you were/what you were saying.
that when women speak up and insist on articulating themselves fully it often rubs people up the wrong way…
Yes, this. I noticed it even in college, where the vast majority of us were strong and aware of the way the system sets us up…we still kept freaking out about being misconstrued above all else.
*waves at bene, falls in exhausted it’s frieday night heap*
Frie-day eh? Well all day I got no fries!
This post is so powerful. I didn’t read the thread you’re all talking about, but I still enjoyed the post. Well done FP.
Thanks SNC – the writing was prompted by the latter part of the thread, but not all directly in relation to it, so much as to a feeling that people prefer it when women stop talking about stuff I guess. But thanks…
Perfect. Yes.
[...] because I missed something important or my language wasn’t sophisticated or I just feel rotten. (Read this.) Sometimes I’ll want to give up. Sometimes I’ll be [...]